I still really love my iPhone but the Android is the second most attractive to me. Like you said though, the devices just haven't been that great yet.
My girlfriend has the Palm Pre and I don't think it's that great at all. It's extremely frustrating to use and the navigation is not that intuitive. My buddy also got the Palm and dropped it a 2 weeks later for the iPhone.
Those Pre keys are way too tiny. I didn't like how it felt after using it for a little bit, and I don't think I'd like it for a long time. I'm really glad Apple went the software keyboard route. It was definitely a smart idea (and it's much easier to type with, too, I feel).
The G1 keyboard is pretty good. Given the amount of money I'm saving, and the fact that I can send emails twice as fast, I'm quite happy to put up with the little inferiorities.
My girlfriend has the Palm Pre and I don't think it's that great at all. It's extremely frustrating to use and the navigation is not that intuitive. My buddy also got the Palm and dropped it a 2 weeks later for the iPhone.