Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I was expecting a new evolution of the unpowered exosuits like [1] that have similar performance enhancement without needing motors and batteries. This is interesting, but the gains seem like they will be minimal for the weight addition until battery tech improves significantly.

[1] https://www.embs.org/scientists-develop-an-unpowered-exoskel...




>the gains seem like they will be minimal

The article and published study quantify the gains:

>The suit weighs about 11 pounds. The team's research, published Thursday in the journal Science, finds that a person wearing this suit expended 9.3% less energy walking and 4% less energy running, compared with wearing no suit.

>That's the equivalent of shedding 16 pounds of weight while walking or 12 pounds while running.

I wouldn't call these "minimal".


Yes, I saw the stats and still think "minimal" is exactly correct. If you read my link, the unpowered version showed an 8% metabolic rate reduction while running. If you put batteries and motors on something, I would expect the gains to be quite a bit better than that for it to be practical.


Idle thought: Is a bicycle an unpowered exoskeleton? What if you clip in to it?


Do you ride on it, or does it ride on you? Is an exoskeleton a vehicle?


Car is more of an exoskeleton in that regard. When you put on the seatbelt, you're wearing the car.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: