Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Not this again:

> systemd is a package of separable utilities

It is absolutely anything but that.

If I want to use GNU coreutils with my own implementation of cat, I can write my own. I have to comply to the interface of GNU coreutils' cat, of course, but as long as I do that, I'm fine.

Good luck replacing journald with your own implementation. The API isn't stable or well-documented, so there is no interface that you'd have to comply with to speak of, and even implementing your own journal reader is officially discouraged.

I often find myself thinking that systemd (which I actually use on my desktop) would be far less hated if the development team would stop claiming things that aren't true. If I break a monolithic program into four parts that can't work without each other and can't be replaced, I'm only meeting a cargo cult definition of modularity.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: