Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

He did the entire 500-page paper in isolation and refuses to lecture on it in any capacity anywhere other than his own university. He may be right, and he may not be, but his failure to get an answer from the community is his fault, not theirs.



Minhyong Kim (cited from the article) makes a good point: that "any journal would probably require independent reviewers who have not studied under Mochizuki to verify the proof."

Given that, Mochizuki is stuck between a rock and a hard place - anyone he brings up to speed automatically becomes disqualified to independently review his work.

I'm not so sure this is entirely his fault.

EDIT: tpyo


While you're correct, part of the fix for that is not to publish a 500-page paper in isolation. You instead publish the underlying concepts piecemeal in "easy"-to-understand chunks (for this insane level of "easy", hence the quotes). This works the same as how good practice when writing code is not to drop a 50 ksloc commit, but rather to do a series of patches showing how you arrived at a given solution.


Math is supposed to be about pursuit of truth, not how congenial you are.


He's welcome to pursue truth on his own, but if he wants other people to read his proof, it's more about the people than the proof.


Come on! Maths is about passing on messages, and this is a human endeavor.


Like it or not, but math these days is a kind of social activity.


[deleted]


My friends and I occasionally joke that the worse a professor's/programmer's/scientist's personal university webpage, the better they are at their actual profession.


It's not the worse mathematician homepage I've seen, by a grand margin. Mine is only marginally better, and I have more to blame since I know what I do when I do webpages :)


When I was in academia, I just used Word (and "Export to HTML") to create my university homepage. Even back then, I knew it was ugly as sin, but I had other things to worry about.

I still don't have a very good sense of design, but I can use Bootstrap. That's good enough.


Seriously. This doesn't even make my Top 5.


Nobody asked you how good he was as a web designer.


[deleted]


It's really not though. It's basically a sign that he's an academic, and again, not a web developer.


did you look at the source, that was written by a mathematician, he took careful care to calculate out every pixel of padding and space. Probably for his specific monitor :)


Nah, those values are generated by "JustSystems Homepage Builder Version 15.0.8.0 for Windows"


A message remains true even after encryption, and yet it's unreadable.


But you can only make sense of it if you have the key... Or already know how to crack the code.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: