I agree with at least some of what TJ Rodgers has to say, though it's a tad too Randian for my taste.
Using cigarette taxes as an example highlights an intrinsic problem with libertarianism: sometimes government is our only defense against "softer" forms of power. Cigarettes are chemically addictive, so selling them means essentially using mind control to generate repeat customers.
Some libertarians want to be free to create value, but others want to be free to con people. Typical Randians like TJ Rodgers don't see the difference, or they grossly overestimate the ability of free human beings to defend themselves against determined and clever con artistry. Much con artistry, such as financial swindling, is very sophisticated when compared with something as ham-fisted as addictive drug pushing. If humans were good enough to resist that kind of thing, there'd be no jobs for stage magicians. Everyone would spot their tricks.
If I were in government and were doing government's proper job, I'd feel good about my work. My feeling though is that quite a bit of government and its related business orbit isn't doing anything like that.
Using cigarette taxes as an example highlights an intrinsic problem with libertarianism: sometimes government is our only defense against "softer" forms of power. Cigarettes are chemically addictive, so selling them means essentially using mind control to generate repeat customers.
Some libertarians want to be free to create value, but others want to be free to con people. Typical Randians like TJ Rodgers don't see the difference, or they grossly overestimate the ability of free human beings to defend themselves against determined and clever con artistry. Much con artistry, such as financial swindling, is very sophisticated when compared with something as ham-fisted as addictive drug pushing. If humans were good enough to resist that kind of thing, there'd be no jobs for stage magicians. Everyone would spot their tricks.
If I were in government and were doing government's proper job, I'd feel good about my work. My feeling though is that quite a bit of government and its related business orbit isn't doing anything like that.