Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>The kind of cryptography that lets people communicate securely?

I don't know of any other kinds of cryptography...

>Belongs on the same list as physical objects that intended to pierce walls and flesh?

War has a lot less to do with shooting people and a lot more to do with information than you seem to appreciate.

The public algorithms are public and there is no need or usefulness in export restrictions now on things known worldwide (and the usefulness of such restrictions was gone for a considerable time before they were lifted).



War has a lot to do with all kinds of things, however optimizing your country for warfare imposes a high cost on civil life and the economy.

You failed to justify the decision of restricting the export of cryptography and the associated costs of that.


This seems a bit harsh, perhaps. Bletchley park was still in the minds of many people. It would have been conventional wisdom to keep this stuff away from "bad guys". Recall, gps was spoofed at this stage as well for civilian purposes. The other issue--although perhaps unsaid--is that ultimately this may have hastened tactics to make HW unsecure, and to collect undisclosed/zero day expoits in widespread SW and other things that could compromise a comms system that was perceived to be secure.


Side-note: nice easter egg on Google when you search for "Bletchey park". Look at the "knowledge graph" result on the right.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: