Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

How is this different from all the other online services that require you to click a link in an email in order to verify it, and refuse to give you full membership until you do so?

Some of the registrars I use have implemented this policy lately. Turns out it's a non-issue as long as your contact info is valid and up to date (which it should already be).

It doesn't conflict with whois privacy, either, contrary to all the FUD that gets spread around. Any whois privacy service that is worth the cost will forward the verification request to your real email address, and if it doesn't, you should switch to a better service. Using a crappy whois privacy service with no email forwarding is a surefire way to lose your domain anyway.




"(which it should already be)."

No, why should domains be required to attached to an individual person?


Domains are required to be attached to an email address that can actually receive emails.

An email address is not an individual person.


It's different because in all other services where you are required to verify your identity, your services do not start working until you do so.

This applies to domains that are already working. If you update your whois record and don't do this, it stops working.

Big difference.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: