Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Agreed.

Xorg + a few fonts is more "heavy" (in memory numbers) than the 90% of those dm/wm,

There are tools like x11perf, glxgears, and more, and at the end of the day, you cannot compare "fluxbox Vs a desktop environment", because you should be comparing fluxbox + cups + a desktop search indexer + a graphical filebrowser + a calendar service + this + that + ...

It's nice to see "the data", as "numbers", but you make a proper point about how it should be interpreted.

When I had more spare time (this is more than 14 years ago), I did test a lot of desktop environments. I did start with kde 1.X, and have use many version of many desktop environments and WMs... my tip is: pick the one that makes you "forget about it" and focus on your tasks.

Now living out of home and al the hardware I carry, and have access does not have any problems. When I loved at my home, I had recycled computers, and repaired by me ones, and if it was not ok for a graphical ENVIRONMENT (I don't care if I don't swap after boot, I care if I swap WHILE USING) I just did use such machine as a "headless server" and everybody is happy.

Other approach to low resources machines as the blog seems to talk about, is to enable remote login (xdm, gdm, kdm, whatever) on a powerful machine, and use the old one to just launch the X (raw) and the remote login/desktop client in full screen.

A few years ago, I did see this numbers on my own for the environments I was interested, and people used to tell me "xfce is light!!!", obviously, they did come from lighter environments, maybe because they were used to heavier desktops. I was used to fluxbox.

I was used to _forget_ about the WM and the backgrounds, and focus on useful things (unless you are preparing a your screen for a Hollywood film or something like that).

I just ask a responsive workflow. Most system do not provide that "by default" and you have to "setup", "cleanup" or "shortcut"... you can do it in many ways at many layers.

I like fluxbox by the following reasons: we did meet years ago, recycling computers with low resources, I did learn the configuration (behavior and keyboard) in half an hour and a few days of tweaking, performance/resources never was a problem, I did forgot about "it" and "it" did let me "do stuff". Until today this never failed/changed. That are my "numbers", I'm a happy customer.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: