Great, now that people are supplied for a couple days let's get into the meat of it. People with wells can supply their neighbors and sell excess water for a nice profit, the police and fire department can take over the reservoirs and help with transport and filling containers...
Okay considering the downvotes I suppose I should have laid out my point at first: We use far far more water than we actually need. In an emergency situation it's not extremely hard to get a couple of gallons a day to people.
Unless by water supply we actually mean turn off the rain. I have no response to that one. That's not going to impact society, that's going to kill almost every bit of land life across the entire earth.
Humanity got by without a lot of things for a very long time. But around 1800, the population begun to climb. After taking 200,000 years to reach our first billion we, reached our seventh just 200 years later. A sudden reversion to the conditions known by America's Founding Fathers would leave ~7/8th of the global population unsupported.
So yes, flush toilets would be the least of your concerns, what with the zombie apocalypse in full swing and everything.