Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> reddit discussion about a type of bowel surgery

Are they really going to register individual topics for Reddit?

Wait,

> Post on social media website X claiming that content relating to protests has been age-gated due to the Online Safety Act.

Now we're reporting individual tweets?!?



I think it is based on tags, so if you tag stuff as NSFW then you get an age challenge.


So if we want to troll Brits online we just post mildly inappropriate stuff in a any random thread and they're instantly locket out until they ID?

That would be hilarious.


Until the laws come to you.


Reddit also likes to randomly tag posts and subreddits as NSFW to force people to make accounts.


The Reddit link works fine with old.reddit. New Reddit has always required an account for nsfw subs.


Yeah it’s nsfw tag based on reddit. So not particularly fine grained or accurate


On this note, how does this work? Do they terminate TLS now?


Who are "they"? British authorities does not block anything directly.

A few sites are covered by DNS/IP blocks by network providers separate to the Online Safety Act, but no sites are - at least so far - blocked by providers because of the OSA. These are mainly piracy related. E.g. The Pirate Bay.

The blocks/age verification due to OSA are done by the sites themselves under threat of steep fines.

This is all in the finest British tradition of passing the responsibility to someone else so you can point fingers when you get blamed. UK authorities love getting industry to "self regulate" as much possible, under threat of more restrictive laws or court challenges when they don't regulate hard enough.

The upside from a government point of view is that these blocks then are hard to challenge in court.


Judging from how most of the reports are phrased, the shutdowns and blocks are initiated by the content providers. Some are for legal reasons, some because they are legitimately concerned that they may be covered by the act, and some to protest the act. Those who are claiming that the government shut down these sites are spreading disinformation. It is more accurate to describe it as a chilling effect.


>Those who are claiming that the government shut down these sites are spreading disinformation. It is more accurate to describe it as a chilling effect.

Same difference. Making a pedantic distinction to mud the waters is the real disinformation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: