Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This trope of "I have nothing to hide" is really tired.

People, it's fine to have things to hide. You can write a blog post and admit you have things to hide. Everyone has things to hide.

For one thing, you can care about hiding the private information that friends have shared with you. Nobody should assume that all their friends and contacts will be super happy about having some stranger at a border paw through their private emails, chats, and photos. Yes, you do have things to hide. It's called basic human privacy.

Please stop saying "I have nothing to hide" unless you're some sort of sociopath who is willing to give up the private addresses, emails, phone numbers, and details of all your friends, family members, and contacts.



I agree, its funny to see the trope from someone advocating GrapheneOS. Like its pretty typical to see from regular internet users who seemingly stopped caring a long time ago that FAANG has essentially their entire life in various databases. We all have private lives, or at least we should, that's just a normal part of being a human.


Plus, I really am working to bring down big government and have been for my entire existence.


Only absolute normie losers have “nothing to hide”. Like, how boring do you have to be


You're taking it too literally, it's to signify, you're not doing anything illegal, you're not doing something you WANT to hide from law enforcement.

Nothing to do with your private pictures or shopping habits. Those are things you want to keep private.

Hiding and Privacy are not the same.


> you're not doing something you WANT to hide from law enforcement.

Why should law enforcement have the privilege to know arbitrary information, especially deeply personal information, about law-abiding individuals?

It is a core requirement of democracy to be able to conceal information from the arm of the state. Political retribution and targeting of ones opponents is not just hypothetical, it's happening now, in America, right now.

Why should law enforcement get to search my phone to find out that I'm critical of the administration? This is information about me that is completely allowed under law, but can be used to discriminate against me.

The definition of legal also changes over time. Giving someone an Uber ride in Texas to an out-of-state abortion center is now a crime. Definitely wouldn't want information on my Uber ride history to be freely available to Texas police. Even if I've never given such a ride, my entire ride history, and possibly my life as a whole, is now subject to deep, targeted scrutiny. Facts would not protect me here, as even if I have done nothing wrong my life could be irrevocably altered. Corruption exists. People make mistakes. Sometimes they have hidden agendas that supersede our shared values of common decency.


> Why should law enforcement have the privilege to know arbitrary information, especially deeply personal information, about law-abiding individuals?

They don't and that's called privacy. Seems I didn't make my point clear that saying "I don't have anything to hide" is perfectly fine when applying to anything criminal.

It's NOT the same as saying "I don't care about privacy".

If you commit a crime and hide that, that's a crime.

If you give out your address, that's not a crime and yes stupid to do, but you're not going to prison for it.

Highlighting that people conflate hiding things with privacy and they're just not the same.


Perhaps you should acquaint yourself with Venn diagrams. The area of overlap between the two concepts is called having something to hide.

You can quibble with the word "hide" but it came from the original post, and it serves just fine. You're free to write your own post that doesn't use that phrasing.


He isn't. It's literally used in bad faith in its literal sense ("if you have nothing to hide, why can't I see your phone?"). Of course, the same argument would never be accepted by the very law enforcement officer who's making it.

The response to that is, yes, I do have things to hide, none of your business.


I have private photos on my phone, photos that I do want to keep private, photos that I want to keep "hidden".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: