Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>> This doesn't mean that honey can withstand all challenges to freshness. Once a jar of honey is open, its surface is being regularly exposed to the air, and dipping licked spoons in will bring bacteria and moisture that weren't there when the jar was sealed.

I have plenty of observational, empirical data that contradicts this apparently theoretical statement. Not just licked spoons but breakfast knives with bits of toasted bread and peanut/butter, Greek yogurt, French moldy goat's cheese, bits of tart, croisssants or other confectionary, etc. All of those can be detected in significant concentrations in my honey jars. Not to mention that simply screwing a lid on an already-opened jar doesn't quite seal it, certainly not firmly enough to cut off the oxygen from it.

Yet I have never known honey to spoil. I mean it's quite remarkable. I think I have seen honey that has stayed at the bottom of a jar for years and it just doesn't go bad. I wouldn't eat it, because it tends to look a bit bleugh, but it won't go off (and that's how it ends up staying in the jar for so long).



Likewise. For some reason the article ignores the raft of antibacterial compounds found in honey:

> Various components contribute to the antibacterial efficacy of honey: the sugar content; polyphenol compounds; hydrogen peroxide; 1,2-dicarbonyl compounds; and bee defensin-1. All of these elements are present at different concentrations depending on the source of nectar, bee type, and storage. These components work synergistically, allowing honey to be potent against a variety of microorganisms including multidrug resistant bacteria and modulate their resistance to antimicrobial agents.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8071826/


Definitely give a little love to your honey jars, it does sound like the relationship is quite one-directional. Even cleaning the spoon/knife before interacting with the jar would increase the long-term stability of the relationship and it's just a nice thing to do for a SO.


Indeed it is. I'm not the one not cleaning the utensils before dipping them in btw ;)


> toasted bread and peanut/butter, Greek yogurt, French moldy goat's cheese, bits of tart, croisssants or other confectionary

You turned your kitchen into a bed and breakfast, though you make it sound like a microbiology lab :)


My honey jars basically turn into forensic time capsules of breakfast past, and still nothing grows


But the same holds for my sugar jar.


Are you all barbarians?

Nothing but clean spoons go in my sugar jar, and I rarely dip out honey with anything but its own dipper - which never touches food.

Reginald, bring me my fainting couch, stat!


We are truly surrounded by heathens. A soiled yogurt spoon in the honey jar?!?!?

[I'm kind of being whimsical here but c'mon - get a squeeze bottle of honey if you can't handle keeping the jar clean plz]




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: