Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't know that i have ever used jpg or png lossless in practical usage (e.g. I don't think 99.9% of mobile app or web usecases are for lossless). WebP lossy performance is just not worth it in practice, which is why WebP never took off IMO.

Are there usecases for lossless other than archival?



I definitely noticed when the Play Store switched to lossy icons. I can still notice it to this day, though they did at least make it harder to notice (it was especially apparent on low-DPI displays). Fortunately, the apps once installed still seem to use lossless icons.

A lot of images should be lossless. Icons/pictograms/emoji, diagrams and line drawings (when rasterized), screenshots, etc. You can sometimes get away with large-resolution lossy for some of these if you scale it down, but that doesn't necessarily translate into a smaller file size than a lossless image at the intended resolution.

There's another problem with lossy images, which is re-encoding. Any app/site that lets you upload/share an image but also insists on re-encoding it can quickly turn it into pixelated mush.


Asset pipelines for media creation benefit greatly from better compression of lossless images and video




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: