Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> humanity has cut a lot of trillions of trees, there are (not enough) trillions left

Is...this true? I thought most logging was in forests that were being cultivated for logging. Can you substantiate this?



I believe we have more trees today then ever before.

That isn't all that matters though. We replant monocultures and harvest them. This isn't a good ecosystem. It's also a net negative on the environmental emissions(carbon sequestered).

The age of the forest, variety, etc all matter a lot.

I spend a lot of time in forests. The difference between a harvested in the last century and an old growth forest is very obvious. They are drastically different.

We don't have a lot of old growth forest anymore.


> We don't have a lot of old growth forest anymore.

Yeah, they burn fast, and... sniff... not only CO2 is released in the process.


This is your 2nd reply to me that's not helpful and/or misses the point.


I'm breathing air polluted by Canadian forest fires as we speak. Maybe you aren't getting the point I'm trying to make?

Almost all issues discussed around here are complex and multifaceted but way too many comments display obstinate tunnel vision... You may want to think about that when you stop crying.


off the cuff, recent news about a satellite to count the worlds trees, mentioned current estimates in the trillions, and it would be way low to suggest that we have not cut 3/4 of the pre bronze age forests.....read the epic of Gilgamesh, and read about the timbers, still holding up the internal chamber in Jhosers pyramid and all of the storys of what north america looked like pre colinisation, and well..... the story of the world and all of the epic forsests that are gone now.....it's all there if you look(archeology,dendrocronology,general historical acounts,etc), humans cut them down , starting in earnest about 10000 years ago, the earliest wooden structure was(likely) shaped by humanitys ancestors more than 1000000* years ago, we kind of owe the trees a break eh!

* yes 6 zeros+, forget the exact reference, but one of the best hominim sites in africa, perhaps oldavi gorge?


> I thought most logging was in forests that were being cultivated for logging

I wonder if you have a source for this assumption?


It's not an assumption - I definitely thought it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: