Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> clans are small states

Nope, clans are definitionally not states for several reasons. A state has definite territory, whereas clan-type structures have tended to overlap with each other geographically because they're usually embedded in some larger society. A state by definition has centralized authority whereas clans may not.

> or whatever label you want to put on the organization that starts with small family tribes and scales to multi-continent empires

There is no such label because these organizations are not just shades on the same theme at different sizes, they're fundamentally different in character.

> that kind of society organization was more or less everywhere in the history of every human society

True, but there are wide variances in how long in the past that form of organization was dominant.

You won't see Egypt reverting to decentralized non-state clan-oriented governance any time soon because they've been ruled by one state or another for 5000 years.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: