Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The FAA doesn't rule on cherry pickers, so that isn't a valid analogy.

Drone regulations are solidly established. The law isn't determined by uninformed commenters on a web forum. And "the effective range of a 12 gauge" will result in jail time. I worked for an autonomous drone company that had a price point around $30,000; destroying one of those could be felony-level vandalism.



Then you entirely missed the point of that analogy. The cherry picker is relevant because the courts are unlikely to rule in favor of my neighbor in that case. Based on that, I strongly suspect they would not rule in the FAA's favor either.

The law, including the bounds of FAA jurisdiction, is determined by the courts. The question is under what conditions navigable airspace supersedes private property rights. This isn't a matter of what regulations the FAA has or hasn't published up until now but rather a question of where either the courts or the legislature determine the FAA's jurisdiction begins.

It also rubs up against state's rights since the FAA is a federal entity. I don't think anyone takes too much issue with the federal government regulating activities 30,000 feet up. Many trees in city parks exceed 100 feet though. By the time you're immediately outside the window of a 2 story house I think it's fairly obvious that the federal government doesn't get any say in the matter.

> destroying one of those could be felony-level vandalism.

Presumably the operator of such would have the presence of mind not to intentionally hover one over my lawn, outside the window of my house, within range of a 12 gauge. If they don't, well, honestly I might chance the courts. It would certainly depend on the circumstances though. Related, I've seen a few videos from the drone's perspective of the fire department shooting it down with water when the operator flew too close to an active house fire.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: