Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is about sunsetting the WHOIS protocol in favor of RDAP, not doing away with domain owner registration data.


It's crazy how many people just read the headline and choose to comment or upvote these links.

Also, why the title is not same as the article? It makes no sense.


To be fair, OP never said this was necessarily related directly to the article.

I’ll often post loosely related tangents like this because I would enjoy discussing the tangent with the HN crowd, but there’s often not a better opportunity to discuss it, so why not while we’re sort of on the topic anyway.

Ack that I don’t think it makes sense to discuss not even remotely related topics. But as long as it’s in the ballpark and it’s not going against other guidelines and leads to interesting discussion, I think it’s fine.


Indeed. Furthermore, the fact that there is still a replacement makes the discussion even more pertinent in this case, since OP is arguing for the abolition of any such protocol.


The site tweaks some words out of titles


I can’t downvote. Not sure about others.


From the link:

RDAP offers several advantages over WHOIS including [...] the ability to provide differentiated access to registration data.


In other words, it provides the ability to monetize and extract more money from people. Like we need more of that...


You clearly read that from a few miles. It is that obvious.

Somewhere enshitification fits all over the place.


Tangentially - RDAP was created partially to resolve issues with PII in WHOIS




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: