Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Aside: it’s pretty amazing what $2K will buy. It’s been a minute since I built my desktop, and this has given me the itch to upgrade.

Any suggestions on building a low-power desktop that still yields decent performance?



>Any suggestions on building a low-power desktop that still yields decent performance?

You don't for now. The bottleneck is mem throughput. That's why people using CPU for LLM are running xeon-ish/epyc setups...lots of mem channels.

The APU class gear along the lines of Halo Strix is probably the path closest to lower power but it's not going to do 500gb of ram and still doesn't have enough throughput for big models


Not to be that yt'r that shills my videos all over, but you did ask for a low powered desktop build and this $350 one I put together is still my favorite. The 3060 12GB with llama 3.2 vision 11b is a very fun box that is low idle power (intel rules) to leave on 24/7 and have it run some additional services like HA.

https://youtu.be/iflTQFn0jx4


Hard to know what ranges you have in mind with "decent performance" and "low-power".

I think your best bet might be a Ryzen U-series mini PC. Or perhaps an APU barebone. The ATX platform is not ideal from a power-efficiency perspective (whether inherently or from laziness or conspiracy from mobo and PSU makers, I do not know). If you want the flexibility or scale, you pay the price of course but first make sure it's what you want. I wouldn't look at discrete graphics unless you have specific needs (really high-end gaming, workstation, LLMs, etc) - the integrated graphics of last few years can both drive your 4k monitors and play recent games at 1080p smoothly, albeit perhaps not simultaneously ;)

Lenovo Tiny mq has some really impressive flavors (ECC support at the cost of CPU vendor-lock on PRO models) and there's the whole roster of Chinese competitors and up-and-comers if you're feeling adventerous. Believe me you can still get creative if you want to scratch the builder itch - thermals is generally what keeps these systems from really roaring (:




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: