Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Well inflating estimates has short lifespans and Scotty got away because Kirk was a meathead.

I like Kirk was shoot first ask later unlike Picard but Picard was always “oh 1 hour - make it in 30 mins” or “1 hour - make it quick you have 15mins”



No, it’s because Kirk respected Scotty and gave him leeway.

Picard is the meathead, if anyone, and actually watching all the episodes in detail and figuring out their characters you’ll realise that Kirk is twice the scholar and then some Picard pretended to be, especially accounting for the movies and later series. Kelvin timeline doesn’t count, of course.

Kirk >>> Picard.


Well I watched only series so far. Not movies.

For me it was looking like Kirk did knew he knows he doesn’t know stuff so he was meathead with ability to defer and not control what he doesn’t know.

Picard was more like he knows everything and had to maintain this aura. But was on a different level of sophistication that I value much.

Even though I love Kirk’s gun blazing.


Oh cone on, we all know that lady captain that smoked 3 packs a day was the goat.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: