Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Godot Responds to Mass Banning – No Apology, Blames Banned Users (lunduke.locals.com)
13 points by overfl0w 4 months ago | hide | past | favorite | 20 comments



In my opinion politics should stay out of software but sadly it gets harder and harder every day. In any case - banning people (some of them contributors and developers) from all platforms only because they suggested that Godot should "focus on software instead of politics" is terrible and harms the project and its community. And all of this started because of a woke tweet which had nothing to do with Godot engine whatsoever. We are living in interesting times. I hope Godot does not follow all the other companies who walked the "go woke go broke" route.


Between this and vaxry’s ouster from freedesktop because his project’s Discord allowed crude and tasteless speech years ago, I’m wondering how many more projects will fracture or make some of their discussion channels private. I believe Free Software will survive social media, but it’s deeply troubling how quickly people insist that they can’t possibly work with someone who has differing politics or worldview in general, or how many actually go and seek out a hill to die on for their tribe. It seems the best policy It reminds me of the old Emo Phillips joke about the Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council. You’ll find a reason to spurn anyone if you look closely enough, and it seems to fill a religion-shaped hole for some culture warriors. https://youtu.be/l3fAcxcxoZ8


This sketch is a gem, I liked it! It is absolutely correct - people can and will divide if this is their goal. Sadly this mass social disintegration on all levels affects negatively various free software products. I don't even hold any extreme political beliefs (I think) but nevertheless I avoid discussing any politics in any professional environment because it's just not the place for these types of discussions and it usually doesn't lead to anything constructive or positive. I never cared what my peers' political/religious beliefs were and through the years never had problems with any of them. It was a simple life - as long as all of us did our job the final products were of decent quality.

Perhaps some kind of a policy which would treat politics as off-topic and would discourage discussing it would be beneficial to such projects in the long run.


[flagged]


i think you have it backwards, you miss where the godot community manager has all kinds of hateful nwords rants? and the people who are hateful just have opinions like "how about we focus on the mission"


Wasn’t that an unofficial discord server mod, not a Godot community manager


seems pretty official to me, its the discord the main site directs everyone to and godot made this person the moderator of. and then that person has access to block people from the official x account?


My understanding is this was the official Discord for years until they distanced themselves from it last year. However, I don’t think there’s an official one, or at least not one that anybody uses.

The community manager blocking everyone on GitHub and X for quoting their founder’s words about not lumping people into groups or staying out of politik is not the same person as the Discord mod “xananax” who was dropping slurs in 2016.

Edit: 0x_rs summarizes events better than me: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41701768


I don't have anything backwards. The community manager never said those things.


so did they ban this person who went on these nword filled rants from godot communities? or do they support that sort of stuff


Why are you asking me? I thought I had it backwards.

You clearly have an agenda with the way you're constructing your statements so let me break this down for you in little itsy bitzy bite sized pieces:

The statements you're referring to were self-referential, so no one is supporting the use of the words AND no one is getting banned for using satirical jokes against themselves. The statements were made by a non-foundation member.

This might be a complicated subject for you to understand, but please know I've tried my very best to make it easy for you.

But hey, if you're really peeved off about it and believe otherwise, it's open source. You can leave if you want to.


i'm not peeved off about anything, just surprised godot supports this person and allow them to go on banning spree's on their "unofficial" (pretty much official) social media's.. over comments that did not go against any guidelines, one person banned from even just quoting a godot founder. you do have it backwards so no need to break anything down to "little bit sized pieces"


Really grasping with all you can aren't ya?


i suppose if you think so lol... i have a link where they break it down into bitezied pieces for you if you want https://lunduke.locals.com/post/6174150/godot-responds-to-ma...


The person you are replying to is what we call a 'cry-bully'.

You know when you've found one by them gaslighting you while accusing you of what they themselves are doing.

The community manager is the hateful one, and did indeed make the comments, enacted the bans, and then doubled down.

You are combating their gaslighting with facts and information, while they keep spouting nonsense and making ad-hominem attacks.

For more on this see what happened with Sony's 'Concord'.


[flagged]


The person I replied to already did that and we clearly see you continue to ignore it.

Here[1] is a video in case you are incapable of reading said article.

[1] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Cq7g9NurIlg


[flagged]


Lol alright I'll play along troll. I now believe you may just be said community manager based on how out of touch with reality you are, and how aggressive and gaslighting when people post facts while posting absolutely nothing substantive yourself. Go back to reddit.

My video I linked explained everything as did op's.

You wre still being a crybully and your gaslighting wont work here.

Since I'm so wrong here's[1] yet another update about godot heing forked over the kerfuffle.

You can call me what you want and live in denial all you want, it wont change the facts no matter how hard you 'Reeee'

[1] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1tvKjDPDlA

Edit to add the video. Troll wont watch but others following the thread will so it's worth it for posterity.


[flagged]


This is way, way beyond the HN guidelines. Reconsider your statements.


Your every single comment here has broken the guidelines Ree Ree

Edit to beanjuice- this is the aforementioned crybully tactic. Break the rules until you do then point the ringer and ree louder.

Again we are fighting facts and they are replying with nothing but ad hominem attacks.l and nothing but.


its just a serious question to someone who's been slinging insults the entire thread


That's not quite true though. Developers, contributors and financial supporters have been banned.

"In a particularly peculiar move, a "Titanium Level" financial supporter of Godot was blocked during this mass banning campaign."

https://lunduke.locals.com/post/6171454/godot-game-engine-en...




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: