Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> A spam advert for a product is still an advert for a product. Therefore it's not just semantic noise, it is still an advert for a product

Ergo slop and semantic noise.

Companies that used adverts which weren't noise went out of business long ago.



Adverts have semantic content, they aren't noise.


Let's just call it slop then. Peak HN: Another conversation is logjammed by nitpicking the precise definition of a word rather than discussing the overall point.


Except I am still discussing the point: the companies won't stop getting an ROI because "slop" still produces an ROI, even if people know it's slop, because it isn't contentless noise, it has semantic content.

Just because you and the others don't understand what point I'm making doesn't mean the conversation is "logjammed". I am still discussing the overall point, you just don't see it.


For the record I agree with you--just pointing out a silly, but common, HN pattern.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: