Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That doesn't make sense to me. Why wouldn't maximizing denials always be the priority for an insurance company? If you make denials slower, it will just slow down all cases.

Insurance is fundamentally incentivized to scam its own customers. We need to add more regulation/oversight to reduce situations where management can play tricks to tip the balance in their favor. It's an arms race.

The article was mostly about optimizing medical director "productivity levels", but it also mentioned that they outsourced to nurses in the Philippines who were doing a really bad job. Is there any oversight there? Are the nurses being incentivized to maximize denials? It'd be interesting to see how their productivity measurements are calculated too.

Of course nothing is going to change (because of something to do with "socialism" I bet), but at least now I know to avoid Cigna.



> Is there any oversight there? Are the nurses being incentivized to maximize denials? It'd be interesting to see how their productivity measurements are calculated too.

I'm sure there's a degree of thinly-veiled abstraction there. "Oh, we never specified such incentives for the outsourced nurses" ("... and while we did specify those incentives for their contract agency, we had NO idea that they'd put such incentives on their employees, none at all!")


> Why wouldn't maximizing denials always be the priority for an insurance company?

I mean it shouldn't be.

Imagine this; you have the choice between 2 insurance companies. One has a reputation of denying all claims and the other doesn't. Which do you pick for your insurance?


> Imagine this; you have the choice between 2 insurance companies. One has a reputation of denying all claims and the other doesn't. Which do you pick for your insurance?

Whichever insurance is provided by my employer.


Yeah but most people don't just pick their insurance.


And as some of the pre-ACA "catastrophic" plans often showed, those who do often go with "whichever is cheaper", and only find out when they get sick how dismal they are.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: