Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

When will cancer be eradicated in humans?



Project manager says next week


After we eradicate it in mice.


Why not just ask when will immortality be achieved?


In two more weeks. :)

In all seriousness, though, is there really such a thing as "the cancer"? Probably not.


Yes? There are lots of variations of cancer, but it seems to be a well defined set of conditions. I don't think I've ever seen an argument over whether something is or is not cancer, or suggestion that such an argument could be made.

Our current methods of treating it treat it in a piecemeal fashion, targeting one variation or another, but I don't think it's unthinkable that you could managed to target and fix the entire set.


Set is an understatement here, there are about ~200 types (as of now), and within a numerous amount of mutations per person. This is why one person could have been treated effectively with early enough detection, and others it just keeps spreading despite treatment. What's even worse, even if treatment does work, it can eventually stop working due to these mutations.

This is why we deal with it piecemeal, because it's the only way we can actually detect it. This isn't a current technical limitation, this is a "we can't solve something before we know the problem" issue due to how cells work. Even in the very long term future where we have bio implants, the best solution we would have are implants being able to seek cancer cells instantly and remove them.


Humour me for a second and think about this in a "sci-fi we have whatever theoretically possible technology we want" fashion.

Suppose scanning technology progresses to the point where we can quickly resolve every cell in the human body. Suppose computing technology progresses to the point where we can quickly interpret that scan data and identify which areas are normal and which areas are tumorous growths that shouldn't exist. Suppose surgical(/point application of energy) technology progresses to the point where we can destroy any individual cell without collateral damage.

I believe at that point we could solve the entire set of conditions called cancer (but maybe not all disease, maybe some forms of dementia still evade us for instance).

I'm not criticizing the current approach by calling it piecemeal. It's what we know how to do, doing it saves lives, of course we should do it. I'm just saying that cancer is a meaningfully label, and it's conceivable that at some point we can solve it, all of it.


In 2 months by a group of 10 humble researchers at a conference in Dartmouth.


Advances in AI could give us tools to accelerate it big time


Accelerating cancer is the last thing we need.


I'm gonna go on a limb and say he intended "accelerate finding treatments"


It’s surprising to me others would take the other side as the default


gonna go out on a limb and say that OP was being humorous


Some would argue lets keep cancer going steady, I say pump the breaks! This bozo says accelerate cancer, this is why we can't have nice things folks!




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: