Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Because basically, I don't think that the trouble they go to creates an obligation in me in regard of my network, my hard drive, my screen.



What a convenient morality you have. "I get to have what I want and have no obligation to anyone else." To bad it doesn't scale.


(I agree with JulianMorrison.)

Why doesn't it scale?


Because people who don't pirate stuff are subsidising those who do and if nobody paid for anything, new stuff wouldn't get made (or at least it wouldn't be available from those people who relied on the income from sales to make a living).


> people who don't pirate stuff are subsidising those who do

Well, the pirates aren't asking the buyers to subsidise them.

> new stuff wouldn't get made

Fine by me.


I'd really like to hear your explanation for why you have no obligation. Just because pirating isn't theft in the technical sense, it doesn't mean you're excempt from paying for someone else's work if you use it for their intended purposes. (as in downloading a song and listening to it)


Somebody probably bought that song originally, and they are sharing it with you.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: