Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[dead]


So you are basically saying that leftist did not kill people, but their demonstrations and riots created an environment leading to people being killed, while comparing it to extreme right terror attacks ?


I would generally consider shootings, bombings, and arson to be a form of terrorism, but I suppose that part may be subjective to some. There was a central repository of all these events for a while, but it's scattered across hundreds of news articles now.


Do you have examples (with a source) of a leftist killing someone for political reason by shooting him, or with a bomb, in the recent events ?

My understanding was the shootings during those event were not politically motivated, just shootings like everyday USA...


Michael Reinoehl was a prominent case. He was wanted for a targeted political assassination:

https://www.cnn.com/2020/09/04/us/portland-protest-suspected...

> Reinoehl's sister, who asked that her name not be used, said in a statement that her "estranged" brother "believed that the country is going to war."

Pipe bombs and incendiary devices were also frequently used against police. Off the top of my head, there was at least one police officer in Chicago who was critically wounded by a pipe bomb, but again the censorship bubble is making this difficult.

There were also numerous targeted assassinations against police officers. Here is one example: https://www.cnn.com/2020/02/10/us/nypd-bronx-officers-shot-m...


> but again the censorship bubble is making this difficult

What is a reliable way of determining whether that statement is true?

For example, do you have URLs of news articles that are not found by major search engines (or are ranked questionably low for the given query)?


"right-wing activist killed"

produces plenty of responses including the Portland protest. Cnn is not on the first page though.

"left-wing kills police officer"

oddly enough produces mostly right-wing violence. Putting "left-wing" in quotes helps a lot though.


> Cnn is not on the first page though.

It is for me. In an incognito tab as well.

> "left-wing kills police officer" > oddly enough produces mostly right-wing violence. Putting "left-wing" in quotes helps a lot though.

Can you give an example of an article that you would have expected instead for that query? I.e. one that you feel has been left out, or ranked too low?


So you mentioned hundred of death... and can only find one (and the killer said he acted in self defense)

The example of attack against the police station can clearly be seen as terror attack. But no dead people there while you were mentioning hundred of them.


> and the killer said he acted in self defense

I'm sorry, but that's misinformation. The killer was on video actively searching for potential targets, and repeatedly referred to himself as a soldier in a civil war. Instead turning himself in, like you're supposed to do in a lawful self-defense situation, he crossed state lines while fleeing from police. He later attempted to shoot the police when they finally found him.

Just because censorship is pervasive does not actually change the historical record. I've posted enough to prove my point. I would invite you to watch the hundreds of hours of violent riot footage instead, but Google already made sure to scrub all of it off of YouTube.


Welp this is quite the goalpost moving, "hundreds of killings" and now we're debating the motives of one single guy.

Hyperbole undermines credibility.


If wikipedia doesn't have it, and right-wing mainstream media doesn't have your supporting facts, it probably didn't actually happen. While I'm sure there's a deranking of pages that meet certain classifications of "hate speech" on Google/Bing/whatever, I've yet to see any evidence of actual political censorship. While I agree that left-leaning media painted the riots in a more positive light or tried to justify them inappropriately, let's not pretend that they killed more people than they actually did.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: