Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> "I asked people in code/design reviews to rename white/black lists to allow/deny lists"

Odd thing to do. "Black" is synonymous with darkness, hidden, off, empty space, and things of that nature. For this reason "blacklist" works. There is no clash with people, or any disrespect.

Politically correct OCD invents problems. Then dictate to others how they should solve those problems. Add penalties for those who don't follow the prescribed solutions to invented problems, and we find ourselves in 2022 looking at Google's efforts to solve the invented problems.

The author of the Vice article states that by removing master/slave and black/whitelist, it "addresses years of habitual bias in tech terminology".

Accusations of bias are just accusations. We can't "find" bias on the grounds of matching words in technical contexts to the same words in other contexts.

In the S&M world, the context is not actual master and slave, it's a new context that encompasses consent and good times. Likewise, the technical context is not one that involves people, but machines communicating under specific rules which "master/slave" adequately describes.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: