Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It gets harder every year to find tax software that isn't owned by intuit... I don't think any of it is free anymore for anything beyond basic returns. The IRS' paper returns get more complicated every year. It seems Intuit is winning this despite all the complaining.



"Cash App Taxes" is owned by Cash App which is owned by Square/Block Inc. It used to be owned by Credit Karma, which was bought by Intuit, but they (were forced?) to sell it.


Ah, thanks for the info. Last I knew Intuit bought Credit Karma (who I did taxes with previously) and I didn't realize they were spun off again.


Yes, the Justice Department mandated that they jettisoned it as part of the sale, as they knew what Intuit would do with it if they got their paws on it.


I found TaxHawk to be really good when I did my own taxes. Mainly I sought it out because it took in K-1's where TurboTax would need an upgrade.


I'd been satisfied with TaxHawk in the past, but when my tax situation changed this time around I tested it with the same inputs as TurboTax with upsells costing 10 times more. After getting the same results on both, I gladly used TaxHawk again.


TaxCut is probably the biggest alternative. Owned by HRBlock. Not sure if the they are better.


But TurboTax does a great job. It’s a good product. Happy to pay for it. Not sure why all of the hate. The problem is the tax system itself, not the software.


> Not sure why all of the hate.

You're being facetious, right?

They have dark patterns every step of the way to try to get you to pay more and to share your tax information. Their "free" is oftentimes not free. And on top of all this, there are countless articles about them lobbying to maintain the status quo of complicated taxes.


Intuit lobbies the government to keep the tax system complicated so they can charge people to use their software.

The majority of the civilized world spends almost 0 time doing personal taxes. Intuit steals our time and money.


> keep the tax system complicated

what happened to the original forces that created this mess. I am not convinced that if it wasn't for intuit we would have a simple tax system.

> The majority of the civilized world spends almost 0 time doing personal taxes.

this isn't actually true.


> this isn't actually true

There are at least 50 countries with less complex taxes than the united states


ok?

What does that have to do with original 'almost 0 time' claim?

Also complexity of american tax code didn't come because of turbotax/intuit. Do you really think we have stuff like credits for home improvements, credits for student loan payments ect are in tax code because of intuit?

There are politicians right now trying to cram in more and more tax code because those incentives are incredible popular with American public. All this is not because of intuit.


You got me "almost 0" was hyperbolic, I'll be more specific: In multiple countries personal taxes can be completed with little more than a signature, and most are simpler in general... the US ranks near the bottom in terms of complexity.

I didn't say that Intuit caused complex taxes, I said they actively lobby to keep them complicated.

Intuit spends millions on lobbying every year (against simplification efforts, as well as efforts for the government to create its own free digital tax filing system) and has recently pulled out of a federal free tax filing program, and are being sued by the FTC for their use of "free" in their marketing and performing bait and switch.


> I didn't say that Intuit caused complex taxes, I said they actively lobby to keep them complicated.

they do? I know they lobby against free website. But i don't see why they nee to lobby for complicated tax code since all the tax exemptions and complexity is widely popular with american public. I cant imagine a politican running on removing home improvement exemptions to simplify tax code.


They've specifically lobbied against automatic filing on multiple occasions, spanning several administrations, and they've also lobbied against tax code simplification.

Are you engaging in this conversation to seek more information, or in an attempt to defend Intuit? most of these answers are a simple google away.


> Are you engaging in this conversation to seek more information, or in an attempt to defend Intuit? most of these answers are a simple google away.

yes i am trying to find how they `lobbied against tax code simplification.` . All the links are pointing to how they lobbied against govt run tax filing system. eg: https://www.propublica.org/article/inside-turbotax-20-year-f...


Again, this isn't hard. You can't oppose an argument by coming here and saying "it wasn't in the first google result"

Same source, different article mentions Intuit's opposition to return-free filing:

https://www.propublica.org/article/how-the-maker-of-turbotax...


> 1. Intuit's opposition to return-free filing

> 2. lobbied against tax code simplification.

1 and 2 are different. yes?

You are right i can tons of examples and articles for 1 but i am looking for 2 specifically.

tax code simplification isn't the same a tax filing simplification.

edit: Yes i am not saying its not simple. 'Tax code' means something specific, its not a generic standin for anything that has to do with taxes. Tax code has nothing do with tax filing itself. I am not sure how to explain this better.


So you're saying that return-free filing is not more simple?

Going to end it the conversation here and log off for the day, nothing personal, it's just a waste of my time to connect the dots in such a painstakingly specific way.


Intuit has been spending billions to lobby for complicated tax filing process and against the government primarily filling out your forms for you based on data they should already have on hand from mandatory reporting. That's why people hate them so much.


I'm not normally one to say "Bro, read the room", but...

Bro. Read the room.

The entire comment section answers the question of "why all of the hate".


> Not sure why all of the hate.

.. I take it you have managed to post this without reading nearly every other comment?




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: