Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> A failure to defend yourself is not aiding the enemy. That is insane.

Let's say you are the leader of a border post, and you leave your post unmanned allowing the enemy in - of course you will be held accountable.

Exposing stuff to the Internet despite the manufacturer warning against it is at least grossly negligent and should be punished.

We are at war with Russia and China on a nation-state level and on top of that we also have cybercrime gangs.




> Let's say you are the leader of a border post, and you leave your post unmanned allowing the enemy in - of course you will be held accountable.

Yes! Because if you are a member of the state operated defense force, then defense is your responsibility. The state is responsible for defense.

If on the other hand, you are a civilian who just happens to own property near a border, you have absolutely zero obligation to defend the border yourself. The same is true for businesses near a border.

> We are at war with Russia and China on a nation-state level and on top of that we also have cybercrime gangs.

Man, if only society had a way to form some sort of governance body which could provide defense against other nations and provide some sort of justice system to protect against and punish crimes. Oh well, I guess its every man for themselves ¯\_(ツ)_/¯


> Let's say you are the leader of a border post

Let's not say that. Suggesting that civilians have defence duties on par with members of the military is ridiculous.


"We are at war with Russia and China on a nation-state level"

Not aware of any country in the world that is currently in a declared state of war with Russia and China.


The insistence of people on a formal declaration of war is one of the reasons why the situation has escalated so far.

Just how much evidence do you need to realize that the actions of both Russia and China have been - for years now - to undermine Western societies and the global set of rules?


Likewise, if I sell... garden fencing, and the military decides to buy it as just another customer, how liable should I be if it's easily bypassed?




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: