Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I will not stop, that exact thing was used to justify that America is the land of the free because you have the freedom to own slaves, the same way BSD is the land of the free because you can take all the freedoms from the users.


Maybe you need a reality shakedown...are you 14 or younger? Because then i just leave you alone, and it's ok to think like that at your age.


Am much much older, but I won't stop because you don't like a perfect valid thing, do you want to censor me or the books where that phrase was printed?

I will also not stop using it each time some dev or software publisher attempts to use a the word "free" in a undefined way to promote something that takes freedom away from others. If you want people stopping doing this you need to be honest and clear, say "BSD gives developers and publishers more freedoms" , or "from a developer popint of view BSD is offering freedom where GPL puts restriction on taking away those "pesky users/products" freedoms" .

I could do an analogy with order relations and ordered/unordered sets but might be too complex so previous well knows quote does the job done, your are the first that got offended so far, maybe you can reflect on why you are so special.


> Am much much older, but I won't stop because you don't like a perfect valid thing, do you want to censor me or the books where that phrase was printed?

You compare a free license with slavery....no one forces you to work on a project that uses BSD/MIT/ISC, also no one forces you to live in the US, that's the "small" difference, no one takes your freedom away.


>You compare a free license with slavery....no one forces you to work on a project that uses BSD/MIT/ISC, also no one forces you to live in the US, that's the "small" difference, no one takes your freedom away.

No, I am not comparing that. You are doing the "comparing" of things that are not comparable. and I am failing to explain , maybe if you know math you understand this

(1,-1) and (-1,1) are not equal but you can't define a natural comparison, if you ignore a component of the vectors you can compare them or if you invent your custom subjective comparison rule you might,

Replace those 2 vectors with BSD and GPL, they are not the same and you can't compare them because there are 2 dimensions, user freedom and dev freedom. If you ignore a component you can compare them, or if you define your own metric then you can say "from a dev point of view BSD is better" and if you say this I will say "True". What people do is something like "BSD is more free then GPL" but ignore the user, the GPL requires you do the decent thing as when you use a GPL code you don't make it less free. so you are not free to make something free less free, you are not allow to remove freedom from something.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: