But unless you're doing a computation without I/O (i.e. no reading back the results, no providing inputs), you need coupling into the rest of the universe, and typically into a low-entropy part of the universe like the Earth, where you have entities that care about the computation. So, I am not convinced having a deeply isolated part of the universe is the answer; in fact, the isolation vs. signal quality tradeoff makes it sound more and more like a fundamental limitation of practical concern.
> But unless you're doing a computation without I/O (i.e. no reading back the results, no providing inputs), you need coupling into the rest of the universe, and typically into a low-entropy part of the universe like the Earth, where you have entities that care about the computation.
With a quantum computer, you can only do that at the end of the computation. Not half-way through; that'll cause the computer to start doing a different (unwanted) computation instead. While the calculation is happening, you need (a high probability of) total isolation from the rest of the universe, so that the intermediate state of the computer only interferes with itself.
> So, I am not convinced having a deeply isolated part of the universe is the answer; in fact, the isolation vs. signal quality tradeoff makes it sound more and more like a fundamental limitation of practical concern.
It is a fundamental limitation of practical concern! Just like the need to keep conventional computer processors cool or they melt, or the fundamental limitations on the bandwidth that a radio frequency can give you. The people who deal with these limitations are called engineers.
