Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Except for the time that Snopes fact checked this article as "disputed": "CNN Purchases Industrial-Sized Washing Machine To Spin News Before Publication". (The article was very clearly labeled as satire.)

https://twitter.com/Adam4d/status/969405110324523008



https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/cnn-washing-machine/

It has the rating "Labeled Satire" not "disputed".


They only retroactively changed this later. Web Archive didn't archive that page for a whole 3 years unfortunately, but you can see in this article that Snopes initially issued the verdict of "false".

https://www.nola.com/opinions/article_ca49020f-5d05-5649-b1c...


So it was labelled "false" and not "disputed" as claimed by nradov? Then it is hard for me to see how this is an example of the phenomenon that hereforphone discusses.


Snopes edited their page after reasonable people pointed out how stupid they looked for fact checking a joke.


Snopes exists in large part because idiots can't discern joke/fake from fact. This isn't really Snope's fault. Some people genuinely don't understand satire. We hear about people sharing Onion articles legitimately still.


Poe's law. I don't know if we need to call people who fall for that 'idiots'. Do people who fall for April 1st jokes count as 'idiots'? Furthermore, can you cure from being an idiot? We used to April 1st a bit on elementary school. I guess I managed to define some idiots back then.


Do you think they look less "stupid" for having to point out that there is no evidence for a cannibalistic, baby-eating cabal of pedophilic Democrat sex-traffickers?

Seems like a pretty thin line between satire and reality these days.


I liked it better when the internet had a sense of humor.


1 is a very small sample set.


did you really expect someone to have published a peer-reviewed study in a high quality journal about how many times snopes was misleading?

The claim was that fact checkers write misleading verdicts with political biases, one example is sufficient enough to verify that claim.


Haha.

Remember that time with Donald Trump quoted "The Babylon Bee"?(BTW, The Bee is CLEARLY Christian Satire) That was pretty good stuff.

A day later, The Bee had an article "Trump declares Babylon Bee the most trusted news in America"


To be fair, in the age of Q, it is kind of hard to find the line.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: