Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Lightning leaves a mess and can be easily determined.



Not true at all. Lightning strikes often leave very little evidence. In particular, if the ground was wet and rocky, a strike some distance away could easily have electrocuted the family with no or minimal burning, and the actual strike location could be nearly impossible to find.

I've seen this with my own eyes. A couple of years ago I watched lightning strike a tree in the park across the street during a rain storm. Afterward the tree showed no evidence of the strike except for some bark blown off. There was no visible burning on the tree or the surrounding ground, but I guarantee that anyone standing near that tree would have gotten zapped.


Ground strikes can kill entire herds of animals with no visible signs of trauma.

I couldn't find any strikes during the time period where they were hiking on

https://www.lightningmaps.org/

map.blitzortung.org doesn't appear to have historical search. But it doesn't mean it didn't happen, just that lightning network didn't record it.

I didn't see any seismic activity nearby either. Thinking that maybe a poison gas flow might have been started by a small earthquake.


Thanks! It didn't occur to me that there might be publicly accessible lighting strike data and mapping, but of course there is, duh.

Do you happen to know the sensitivity of the network? That is, the percentage of lighting strikes they expect to catch?


I don't know that, but they are great questions for lightning researchers. The premier lightning research org (to my knowledge) is in New Mexico.

https://www.nmt.edu/research/organizations/langmuir.php

http://www.lightning.nmt.edu/nmt_lms/

Let us know what you find out!


Was talking to a vet, they claimed that most cases of herd's dying "from lightning" were botulism related or other poisonings. The herds graze together, and can die together.


Doesn't being electrocuted leave a weird scar with the paths of least resistance the electricity takes?


A few lightning strike victims have been left with Lichtenburg figures on their skin:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lichtenberg_figure

But this is an extreme symptom of a direct or nearly direct hit. Many lightning victims have no visible injury.

Lightning isn't very good at killing people, but it's capable of hurting you from a great distance, because it takes so little current across your heart to cause problems. There is evidence that as little as 5 mA can cause cardiac arrest, and this is the rationale for GFCI protected outlets in homes:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Residual-current_device


You can get a sufficiently large shock to stop your hearth without any tissue damage.


Not always. We lost two horses to a lightning strike and if not for us being there at the time, we'd have had no idea why they died. They were both lying dead on the ground with a mouthful of grass and no signs of injury.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: