Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> GameStop's financials were and are pretty solid.

But aren't stock prices almost entirely about future performance? So will GME's business model work tomorrow?

I think the answer is yes. They're the best option for buying used peripherals that I've found. I can get it right away, can exchange easily if a problem and can see the item before I buy (or at least when I pickup).

I've just wasted too much time trying to see through the Amazon reviews gaming, do what feels like national security background checks on eBay sellers or go through the hassle of FB marketplace.

Maybe it's just me, but as a casual gamer and fan of legacy consoles, I like shopping at Gamestop. Whether online with "at the door" pickup or in the store. The locations around me have employees that seem genuinely happy. Maybe they're good at hiding their misery.

If Gamestop would expand into more hobby shop items, it could really take off. Board games, miniatures, etc. And why don't they stock energy drinks (my locations don't anyway)? Post-pandemic add small cafes with rentable game systems. I think people will be desperate for actual human interaction once that's possible again.

Finally, with this ongoing retail apocalypse maybe their leases will get cheaper.



> But aren't stock prices almost entirely about future performance? So will GME's business model work tomorrow?

Yes, and that's sort of Roaring Kitty's point in that video. He interpreted the negativity about it as being way too extreme for the financials of the company. It was basically saying the company was going to fail tomorrow, whereas his analysis said to him that it still had several reasonable years ahead of it which the share price didn't reflect.


> But aren't stock prices almost entirely about future performance?

This depends on what kind of investor you are. Do you believe the market is entirely rational and depends on the underlying fundamentals of a company? Or do you believe that the stock market is ultimately irrational and trades solely on hope and fear?

Frankly, I don't see how anyone can disagree that the market is entirely irrational and solely emotionally based, and the reason is because humans are irrational and emotionally based. We rationalize our positions after we've taken them, not before, I'm totally convinced of this, mostly thanks to Sam Harris, and to a lesser degree, Richard Dawkins.

We want to believe that we logically poured over the facts and figures and we arrived at the only inescapable conclusion possible. Were that true, everyone would arrive at similar conclusions. Despite what some people have said the past several years, there are no such thing as "alternative facts". A thing is either true, false, or unknown.

Smarter people than I have made cases on both sides of this argument, but for me, I see it happen every day, all the time, all around me. I watch it happen in finance. I watch it happen in book publishing. I watch it happen in development. I, for one, am a believe in what I call the "emotional market hypothesis". Hell, Tesla is a perfect example. There's absolutely no reason for a stock to be trading at 1660 times its earnings, but Tesla is. That's its Price-To-Earnings ratio right now. The stock is fueled by hope. Elon is the personification of that hope, for better or worse.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: