Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Would Firefox Sync be an alternative?

It could allow transparent use of Firefox and Chromium data with the same account with history, passwords, bookmarks shared and the rest of the options and add-ons segregated by browser.

Firefox sync also has "Send Tabs", which -to me- is a great feature.



Yes. I'd love to see a Firefox Sync implementation for Chromium, which would make it easier for people who use Firefox but occasionally need to run Chromium to open something that doesn't bother to handle browser compatibility.


Brave Sync would probably be a better fit. Brave is already built on top of Chromium, it's open source, and they recently "rebuilt [it] to be more directly compatible with the Chromium sync system" [1]. It's also E2EE and doesn't require an account.

[1]: https://support.brave.com/hc/en-us/articles/360047642371-Syn...


Brave literally injects code and alters the UI of sites you visit to sell dubious cryptocurrencies.

It boggles my mind when people recommend Brave in a privacy/security context.


I think what you're describing are the "Tip" buttons which can be added on a few supported sites (which can be disabled). They aren't selling anything- it's a feature which people can use if they like.

The server implementation for sync is mostly compatible with Chromium and can be used without Brave. Someone could clone https://github.com/brave/go-sync and stand up their own server. It would require some patches on top of Chromium (similar to what is done in Brave) to implement the authentication - but once that is done, all of the Chromium tools like chrome://sync-internals work just fine


> Brave literally injects code...

Source?



Brave will sue you if you try to use its services with a different browser. https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/1269890055822118912?s...


The service itself is open source and can be hosted by a community. It has a different authentication scheme (ex: not Google accounts) and enforces client side encryption by default. See https://github.com/brave/go-sync for more information

The official service hosted by Brave is only intended to be used with Brave Browser


Potentially, but when I looked at Firefox sync to see if I could implement a custom version, the spec was kind of crazy complex.


GNOME Web has implemented it though, so that could give some hope that this is feasible for Chromium as well.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: