Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I personally don't want government to mandate speech policies on private companies and think people should be allowed to join websites that enforce values they like and agree with. My woodworking forum should be allowed to have a "no politics" rule. A Christian dating site should be allowed to ban atheists, like me. A social media app should be allowed to ban hate speech -- I don't want government making it illegal for there to be communities without hate speech.

Unless you're suggesting government should just ban hate speech? I don't favor that, either, but maybe I should ask for clarity here.




For 'normal' companies this definitely would be absurd, but I think a good amount of these incredibly large companies should essentially be regulated as a public utility.

>Unless you're suggesting government should just ban hate speech?

For 'published' speech that is, essentially like libel. I know that censorship laws can be dangerous, but it realistically just strikes me as the lesser evil. You evidently can't just let that stuff openly fester, but I simply can't imagine a situation where the government would suppress 'good' speech but a company with equal power wouldn't.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: