Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The Senate doesn’t represent the “people”. It represents the states.

Senators are elected by the people of those states.

> Each state regardless of population has 2 senators. Meaning that 46% of the Senators represent less than 25% of the population.

It's not a direct proportional representation. That's what congress is.

> The purpose of the legislation is to enact the will of the states.

Congress also makes legislation.

> A powerful government can do much more harm than a corporation. There isn’t a single corporation in America that has the coercive power if the government.

Thankfully.



The Senate is far more powerful than the House. They also approve judges with lifetime appointments, Cabinet members, and committee chairs - where regulations are actually chosen.


And they are still elected by the people. Just because senators are not proportional to the number of constituents and instead proportional to the number of states does not mean they doesn't represent the people - they represents the people of a state but in a non-proportional manner. You haven't made any points against that since I pointed it out, and it completely negates your original point, so I'm not sure what you're trying to accomplish by noting the Senate is more powerful. They are, in some respects, but that's irrelevant as to whether they represent the people. Also, Congress has quite a few unique capabilities as well, such as oversight, impeachment, the ability to declare war. Powers are split between the two parts of the legislative branch.


If I lived in California, why would I want the states in the Bible Belt to have a disproportionate amount of power?

How did that whole impeachment thing work earlier this year? Wasn’t it stopped because a disproportionate number of Senators to the population stopped it?

How often have Presidents used military force when the majority of the people weren’t in favor of it?

Judicial, Cabinet, and Committee are all decided by the Senate.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: