I love good commit messages as well, but it can be hard to convince people to write them. I always hear "Why? i don't use them" which is self propelling. You don't have good messages, so you don't read them when you want to know something, so you don't write good commit messages.
I don't really do comments all that often (generally, only for "Chesterton's fence-esque" things) but I do really rely on good commit messages. They are really helpful when going back in history and trying to get a general idea why something changed.
