Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Probably an incredibly stupid question but I've always wondered why we can't take small amounts of nuclear waste - say, size of a AA battery, put it into a metal package and use it in laptops / cars / whatever. Short of the risk of leakage, the amount of power that can be generated from it is surely enough to power a laptop or put them into a battery pack for a car, no ?


Russia also made one of these as a prototype and it was ~90 mm3 & 0.35 g for ~1 μW of electrical power ( https://newatlas.com/nickel-nuclear-battery-design/54884 )

So to power a laptop you'd need a really, really, really big & heavy battery. Like, the size of a house big.


How many watts do you want? In a standard RTG, you need 20 watts of heat for every watt of electricity.

That and the "what if this gets breached" factor are the main problems.


> Short of the risk of leakage

That's the main risk. A major cause of civilian radiation accidents is radioactive material accidentally mixed with unlabeled scrap [1], and if you put any noticeable amount of the stuff into products meant for untrained civilians, the rate of that happening would skyrocket.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_civilian_radiation_acc...

For a particularly nasty example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samut_Prakan_radiation_acciden...


I'm not an expert but I know of two different technologies to convert heat to power: thermocouples and heat engines.

Thermocouples are great because they're small, can fit in enclosed spaces, have no moving parts and last nearly forever. However, they're not a very efficient way to convert heat to energy.

Heat engines + generators can be very efficient, but they're bulky and have many moving parts (you're not going to attach a diesel generator to your cell phone).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: