Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Who cares about the dmca? Just ignore it and live consequence free


> Who cares about the dmca? Just ignore it and live consequence free

The people distributing the software are at greater risk than those downloading it.


The risk is basically nothing. You get a notification saying "don't do that again". In my younger days I helped distribution with various scene groups to the tune of terabytes of files. I think I got a few notices that ended in the garbage. At the time I was getting cracked copies from employees of ILM and pixar


A bunch of people have gone to prison, or been put on probation/house arrest and had to pay large fines.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Fastlink

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Buccaneer

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Site_Down


The odds are lower than winning the lottery.


Yet people win the lottery every day.

The EFF exists for a reason. Hopefully not a reason that you'll ever personally need, but if that day comes and the hammer comes down on you, you'll be thankful people prepared for that situation.


1 in a 180 million. What is your point?

The eff doesn't exist to defend pirates so that is irrelevant.

Pirating in every shape in form has to be one of of the lowest crimes to get caught for. And most cracks come from overseas so good luck there.


> The eff doesn't exist to defend pirates so that is irrelevant.

That depends on your definition of piracy. The EFF strongly fights against the DMCA.

> Pirating in every shape in form has to be one of of the lowest crimes to get caught for.

Low in terms of what? Punishment? A fair number of people have received harsh punishments, as already mentioned. You mention you were caught distributing a lot of pirated material, so the probability of getting caught seems high. The fraction of people that received a non-trivial punishment of those caught distributing a lot of pirated material is higher than 1/180 million.


No I did not mention I was caught in any significant way. I never had a worry in the world about getting caught. Outside of receiving a no consequence piece of paper in the mail that means nothing.


Jeffry Reichert was sentenced to 1 year in prison for soldering a modchip onto a Wii.

https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=138975038570173...


So he had a for profit business selling mod chips. That's totally different than downloading some files


It matters for the people that create and distribute the cracks. Its much easier to simply dump the crack file/source on your website and freely distribute it if its legal to do so.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: