Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Does anyone know a simulation of the solar system corrected for delta-v?

It would be neat to see visually how the planets compare. Like a 3D rendering, or a screensaver.

You'd need to morph distance such that if a point takes less energy to travel to from earth, it appears either closer or larger.

Bonus points if it accounts for time dilation somehow.




There is a delta-v map (not to scale) of our solar system that could be used as the basis of this:

https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/1ktjfi/deltav_map_of...


One of the more interesting consequences of orbital mechanics is it takes far more delta-v to get close to the sun, than it does to leave the solar system entirely.

Think about this in terms of how fast the earth is moving to avoid "falling into" the sun, anything that leaves the earth has that velocity too.


If you do a Hohmann transfer — the most basic sort, used by most Δv calculations — from Earth to the Sun, yes. But if you give yourself solar escape velocity (a savings of about 59% in your hyperbolic Earth escape velocity, which works out to a huge savings of about 18.9 km/s Δv if you do your burn in Low Earth Orbit), then once you get very far from the Sun you can stop yourself virtually for free, and fall straight down. The whole trip would take decades though.

The same basic idea works for reaching any inner object orbiting any body.

In practice you can probably do better by aiming for a planet and slingshotting, but that gets more complicated.


This illustrates why being in a Earth orbit is really “Halfway to anywhere” [1] in the solar system. Well, at least to where you would like to land.

[1] A book by Harry Stein about single stage to orbit attempts. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._Harry_Stine


What's funny is that in terms of delta-V, the surface of Deimos (Mars' second moon) is actually closer to us than the surface of the Moon.

Of course in travel time the distances are very different. Delta-V is not the only factor that matters.


Interesting. How does that work for Deimos specifically? I've read that landing on Mars takes less delta-V than the Moon because you can aerobrake, but that doesn't apply to Deimos. Is that because of its nearly nonexistent gravity, or is there some other factor?


Direct link to the image: https://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png


Kerbal Space Program?


Not exactly a simulation but it is a nice illustration, I think.

https://xkcd.com/681/


Came to ask the same question. I would love a nicely animated screensaver that has planets spinning round and highlights the current orbital configuration




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: