Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Related to this, I remember when HN was showing the amount of upvotes on comments (like it does on posts).

I still miss it, because quickly scanning a very thick amount of content, I'd like to know where I should spend time. I do it with posts (and the list /best is great if you're short on time).

The ordering still supposedly shows us the very recent followed by the 'solid comments', but there is 0 information about how 'solid' that comment is by consensus.

That being said, my favourite part of HN is the [-], so when I'm done with someone's opinion and their 300 responses, I can just skip it.




Funny thing: I still don't know what [-] means, there are no tooltips or any other hints so I prefer not to click it.


It's just a simple collapse thread feature.


Not so simple; it persists the collapses somehow (I think server side attached to your account rather than your session.) That’s a lot more complexity than the equivalent Reddit feature, for a change.


Hm... I always thought it has to do with the comments that get slowly grayed out? E.g., for me that was basically a "downvote".


There is a downvote button, but you need some minimum karma for it to be available to you.

I can understand why it might be confusing if there's no downvote arrow visible!


Yeah, that some kind of UX pardigm - don't hide the control. Disable it, and explain the user why he cannot use it at the moment.

On the other hand, though, I can now simply collapse huge branches without downvoting anyone, so thanks for the clarification! :)


[-] just hides that branch of the comment tree so that you can ignore it if you want to focus on reading other branches.


You've been here since 2012! :)

That's really interesting.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: