Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

* Setting a timer or an alarm

* Asking for the weather

* Play some (desired) music

Are there other things that these devices ("smart speakers") are really useful for?

A voice activated browser or computer, on the other hand, is extremely useful for those who don't know to type or to use a browser (or a computer). It could be people who are not privileged enough to learn or people who find these very difficult to learn or even small kids. These systems allow the user to accomplish what they want (like searching or opening a website or a game, for example).



I'm very skeptical about this as well but an argument I saw on here that I found kinda convincing was a comparison to the usual job of a "secretary". Most interactions are verbal and there's a wide variety of tasks that can be solved that way. The real problem is trust in an automated system handling those correctly, which is solvable.

Think, for example, sorting your email inbox by "importance", not based on some flags or fixed heuristics but an actual, intelligent scan of the contents. Think of having reasonable phone conversations that result in scheduling appointments and answering concrete questions.


Though it's in the same vein as "Asking for the weather" I find a lot of use for finding out when my next bus is coming, how the traffic is, and other things related to my commute. And calling for Ubers.

But as I said, they all fall under the category of "mildly useful" and not "ground breaking"


The only other thing we really use it for is calling from room to room, as a glorified intercom.


For me the big one is easily adding items to lists (e.g., Wunderlist) without having to stop what I'm doing.


* unit conversions

* controlling smart-home stuff

* child/baby monitor

* intercom

* home telephone




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: