Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Author may want to implement a labelling method for users for a days to maybe train the discriminator a little bit better. Would be a cool human-in-the-loop exercise.



Yes something like this: http://www.whichfaceisreal.com/


I was surprised to see that the easiest way to figure out if a face was real was by looking at the background. The face generator seems to be terrible at everything but faces. There are often strange visual artifacts and clipping issues, and the face generator never seems to put another person in the background of the picture.


Wow. I got 2/10 the first time and then did again after reading your comment and got 10/10. The background really does give it away.


also, the teeth. in generated images they are usually strangely asymmetrical


I got some pretty tough ones on mobile. Maybe if I had zoomed in I would have seen the differences.’, but eh: https://imgur.com/a/UXSCOG8


Very unusual expressions seem to me likely to be real, simply because the generated images are AFAIK in a sense statistical averages.


I thought this too! Then I picked a weird expression and was wrong lol.


The fake image looks extra weird because it looks like he has glasses on the right side of his face but its kinda cropped out


Seems like the algorithm considered his baggy eye pockets as the bottom rim of a pair of eye glasses.


Ahah. I didn’t see that, and I have pretty bad vision myself.


I read this as "which France is real" and was slightly disappointed when I wasn't able to test my incomplete knowledge of European geography against a neural net.


ML generates some rather bad artifacts. Just look for those.

Even in this[1] difficult comparison you can see the non-human repeating skin patterns on the right and the awkward teeth contour. Also hair-on-skin often looks wet and with unnatural bends.

When comparing wrinkly people then it gets a little harder.

1: https://i.imgur.com/KWnhkBS.jpg


That one is super hard when looking only at the face.

Look at the clothes and necklace. The clothes are different on left and right sides of her face - the moment you see it you can't unsee it and it's obviously wrong.


After yesterday's 10 minutes of watching those fake faces this test was super simple for me, I did like 25 without mistakes which kinda shows the fake generation has a long way to know to fool good eyes.


Look at the eyeball, compare reflection, it’s easy this way.


Wow. I have no idea which face is real.


You can pretty reliably guess correctly if you look for ghosting/blurring/chromatic aberration along sharp edges, e.g. around the eyes, on the chin, and in hair. ML hasn't quite mastered the fine details yet




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: