Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Speaking about a few cons from an H1B perspective from countries like India.

1. The nature of H1B Visa makes it inherent for people to not take the risk of working at a startup. Part of the problem is the short time between layoffs and finding another job. H1b's may have very little time[1] to search for a job after a layoff. A startup could make it easier for them. Short of a layoffs due to financial reasons, startups could have a decent protocol for making the transition smoother. If the engineer is not a good fit, unless he is terrible, he can work a few months more until he finds another position. A few weeks notice as a standard is very little and keeps good engineers away from startups.

2. Some startups process Green Cards(GC) only 1 year into employment as a part of their "policy". This is partly understandable as GC processing is a bit costly. But the cost is not that much(<10,000 based on my experience)[2, 3]. So this 1 year hard stop is non-sensical from a monetary standpoint(especially with developer salaries running in 80-150K over many years)[4]. It also creates a sense that GC is being used as a carrot and stick approach to make people stay, this is morally questionable because for the H1B's have a lot at stake (pack bag and go to india if you don't find a job fast enough, disrupting family and personal lives). A better idea would be to process it immediately as Google/FB etc do. This gives a lot of people confidence to work and even if it does not work out its not that big a deal.

PS I can vouch that a GC is more important than 10K$ here or there in the long run.

[1]At the moment a one time 90 days grace is provided thanks to a 2017 USCIS rule(which is plenty), but it can be only used once per H1b VISA. i.e. if you use that up once you can't use it again.

[2] http://www.immi-usa.com/eb2-green-card-cost/ [3] http://www.immi-usa.com/immigration-attorney-fees/ [4] https://stackoverflow.com/jobs/salary/results?l=San+Francisc...



That's an excellent point about the terrible H1B grace period policy. A lot of good companies have an informal policy about that, but I agree it needs to be more widespread. Do you know if any companies offer that policy publicly?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: