Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

How long before we see a post that people are being fooled into installing some copycat apps which are nearly identical to original apps but are getting promoted by Search Ad Basics?



I've made this mistake already. The search ads show apps that are very similar-looking to what I am obviously trying to find.


How long? You can already do this with the existing search ads.

By promoting your app through search ads you are greatly increasing your chances of getting detected by app review or the company you are cloning very quickly. Meaning you are going to get pulled pretty fast, and are still paying for it. I don't see how the economics would work out.

Tt is more used for competitor apps stealing the top search result for things they aren't ranked highly for.


Isn't Apple's detailed vetting the difference between the App Store and Google Play? Apple should be able to catch these scammer apps.


Maybe 5 years ago, but I don't think they have any quality bar now. For every decent quality game on the app store there are dozens of terrible clones: https://youtu.be/yU6WC4dpaHM?t=12s


Omg that first one even uses the default Unity player model, it looks worse than most Ludum Dare games


Cant wait for Grab that auto V: Online


You'd think, but they still let some absolute trash through:

http://bylr.net/3/2017/11/99month-is-a-steal-for-cloudapp-fo...

It's incredible that on one hand, they can pull up competent and dedicated developers for a minor transgression, but then allow something as ugly and misleading as the above example.


I know it first hand. Our app has an auto-renewing subscription, and they are nitpicking every little detail on it (Not letting us say "Free Trial" even though it is literally a free trial for a week, with the subscription price/renewal stated clearly on the same view.) Yet an app like iHeartRadio has a "Free Trial" button with no visible terms, no visible price, and no renewal frequency listed gets a pass.

Plus they let those scam VPN apps through with a "Free Trial" that immediately charges you $99, and they stayed at the top of the grossing charts for days. It is insanely frustrating. The app review process at Apple is a joke now, honestly. I'm pretty sure it has been outsourced to some third party, we always get through on appeal, but why should a year old app with a 4.6 star rating with thousands of reviews have to appeal every single update submission.

Sorry for the rant, just dealing with this exact problem as we speak.


App Review hasn’t been outsourced to anyone.

As far as every single time having to appear — have you considered making the change that wouldn’t require an appeal?


Thing is you can just keep trying to submit crap until you find somebody off-guard.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: