Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This works well for the those rare people with the luxury over control of those settings in their workplace.

I actually like the Automatic Update feature. I don't need to remember to run updates myself all the time. That said, I've been bitten by an hour-long unusable computer scenario and it's been a bummer, to say the least.




> ...rare people with the luxury over control of those settings in their workplace.

Would you kindly provide a citation for that statement?

I've been programming on Windows for twenty years in various corporations - never had a problem getting Admin rights on my own machine... I'm now a consultant and I visit many, many, many job sites - and I just don't see it being a problem.

Furthermore - Linux wouldn't solve the problem for those rare people who can't control their settings anyway. So, what's your point?


It's a huge problem in more restricted environments - e.g., investment banks. Admin access can be very hard to come by.


OK whether it's a problem or not is definitely up for debate.

The bigger point here is that switching to Linux would not help those people either.


Clearly you've never worked for a major UK bank. Sure there may be a handful of very specific developers who get full admin rights over their machines where whatever they're developing requires elevated privileges, but these machines are often sandboxed.

In many cases you're stuck as a "Power User" or whatever group policy the IT department deems sufficient for you to run Visual Studio (or IntelliJ etc). Been there done that twice in my career.


Right, but switching to Linux will not solve anything for those people either because they will not be allowed to do that either.

The person who wrote this up article obviously has complete control over their computer don't they?


I got bitten by this last week and again today. I had previously configured Windows 10 Pro's custom restart time such that my machine would not restart until x days later at a specific time if there were pending updates.

I've always kept on top of this every day and check each day to see if there are any pending updates and have always installed these updates within 12-24hrs of them appearing, or nudging back the restart time by a day or so if it's not been convenient. This approach has worked fine for months....until just recently.

In a recent update the "Use a custom restart time" feature has been disabled and all I can do now is specify my "Active Hours".

I even had the Local GP setting you suggested configured as well.....but Windows 10 really needed to reboot my PC, ignoring my "Active Hours" and any and all of the Local GP settings you can throw at it. Twice in the past seven days I've been given the 20 minute warning and there is damn all you can do about it....despite all of these workarounds and overrides.

In all fairness I think the author of the article has probably just had it up to the back teeth with Windows 10 and the seemingly new ways it finds to totally fuck up your working day. I've been a MS developer for 20 years, I really like Windows 10 but I've gotten pretty close to the author's levels of exasperation myself over the past few days with some of its control freakery.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: