Honestly it's one of those YMMV things, as you say there is no right answer. That's why I said "for me" :) People are different and drill into information differently as well.

Most of the arguments I've had over the years on this subject were cases where we were both right. To them X was more reasonable and to me Y was, and the two were mutually exclusive.

As I write this it makes me wonder if this whole topic is a fool's errand, are we doomed to forever be trying To solve an unsolvable problem?