Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
What Cost Is Each State Obsessed With (fixr.com)
40 points by bennettfeely on Aug 3, 2016 | hide | past | favorite | 23 comments



I would look at Google trends rather than autocomplete. Their autocomplete tries to be smart and doesn't reflect actual search traffic.

See: Why won't my parakeet eat my diarrhea.


Looks like it only returns words that begin with consonants because of the "a". If you search for

"how much does an * cost in"

You get different results that begin with vowels as well as acronyms/abbreviations.


This study has ruined is ability to be reproduced, as whenever you attempt any of the searches, you get the study and many articles about the study, in the results, which reinforces the findings of the study.

It's a self-reinforcing study! The more you test it, the stronger its validity becomes!


As others have already stated, there are some problems with this "study." I'm too lazy to do this myself, but my guess is that when you actually redo this auto-complete search, and look at not just the top search, but rather the top 5 searches, you will find a lot of overlap in many of the state searches, which will probably show less state variation (with some exceptions of course, and possibly more regional homogeneity, which would be interesting.)


I love NY and Vermont.

Pound of Weed ----> Cord of Wood


I posted this as a comment on the article, but I'll share here as well...

This is kind of funny, but the methodology is suspect. For example, Lincoln Nebraska is a college dominated city so the result is no surprise, Omaha Nebraska has a much larger population and not really skewed so much toward a single demographic. When I run your search for Omaha the top result was drivers license. However we all know that your personal search history can affect results and I had been researching voter ID laws. When I try the search in a new incognito window... I get no results whatsoever! So, unfortunately, I'm going to have to firmly place this in the humor category.


I think the methodology here is off. It may not be that People in Florida and Alabama are looking for abortion prices. It could be people in Georgia price shopping neighboring states, then looking for taxis to get across the border.


Right - best example of that is "How much does a fishing license cost in Montana". People outside Montana are probably going to drown out people inside Montana.

There aren't that many people in Montana


This is a horrible metric; tons of these are clearly people googling about things somewhere other than where they live (c.f. Alaska, "gallon of milk").


Other comments allude to it, but this one should be at the top as it gives a good example as to why the methodology is suspect: pretty sure people in AK know what a gallon of milk costs in Delta Junction. I, a WA resident, would have to look it up.

There are other, similar examples of course. Price of weed in CO? Yeah, maybe residents are looking, but I'm more inclined to think the girl in Detroit is wondering, "I'm paying $250/quarter for pot, I wonder how much it costs in states where it's legal?" If I want to know how much weed costs in WA (where it is also legal), I pull up the website of my local store, not ask Google.


This doesn't show California as obsessed with the price of housing, so I have to assume the methodology is flawed in some way.


"Succession" in Louisiana

I don't care if the methodology is suspect, I WANT TO BELIEVE...


It either means inheriting an estate (LA has a very unique legal system) or it means "LA IS LEAVING THE US!!"

And the United states gross income per capita and IQ went up by 100%.


Funny when you've contributed to your state's thing at least twice. I wonder whether it's the humid heat, or the need to chill lots of beer and cheese that makes Wisconsin obsessed with electricity.


Kentucky and Florida should make some sort of deal.


I'm not at all surprised to see what my hometown of Bismarck, ND is obsessed with.


Does "a minor" have a different meaning, or is there a thriving underage slavery ring there?

I suppose it could also be "a minor ticket" or "A Minor" (the scale).


It costs a lot to import those Aeolian modes all the way from Greece to North Dakota.


Add 2015 to the title please.


Vermont is so quaint.


"The T" ??? What's Massachusetts going on about?


Boston subway system.


The more commonly used name for the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_Bay_Transportati...




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: