Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Not to be flippant, but "Anarchist extremists believe that society should have no government, laws, or police, and they are loosely organized, with no central leadership" is a core belief of both libertarian Republicans like the publicly-visible two Koch brothers but also, to a lesser degree, some more educated, but unworldly, people whom happen to also believe that government "just gets in the way" until Flint, Michigan water crises and Hurricane Katrinas happen. Perhaps also criticizing ineffective and wasteful government, apart from deliver services or enforcing laws, may also be viewed as a potential tool to silence critics, whom have the significant power of social media. In Europe, a continual attempt to balance between anarchy and Big Mother is called democratic socialism, although the coloring of the word "socialism" implies Big Mother communism in many older Americans' minds... this is unfortunate when there are many more "Jungles" dispersed around the US than all of Europe and people living in their cars in the shadows (both situations are "bad"). I hope the US and more countries get a basic income soon.

Parents should also be upset at the thoughtpolice sort of world this kind of policy reinforces. It's bad enough the FBI monitors social media of security researchers and calls their employers should they be tagged or take photos with "watchlisted" people... this already happens, today, and it's not just some tinfoil wingnuttery. Considering how low the bar is for millions on various watchlists, how must it feel to become "radioactive" without a trial or even hard, unclassified evidence? Fear and gossip are powerful motivators, especially threatening people's careers and reputations.

I think this sort of thing sets a dangerous precedent when the re are already programs like https://www.dhs.gov/see-something-say-something




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: