Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Businesses can obtain damages from governments, if those governments are found to have enabled trade policy that contravenes the treaty. Businesses cannot go to ISDS for damages from citizens or companies in those countries.

I don't know what one thing you don't like in the TPP has to do with the level of transparency involved in its ratification. If the ISDS process is a grievous flaw, rather than a mechanism that is similar to those used in many/most other trade treaties, surely it won't be ratified.

Either way, you'll soon have the full text of the treaty, months before it comes to a vote.



"Surely"? Only when there's sufficient protest against it.

The reason why the secrecy makes ISDS even worse is that it undermines democratic means of the people to improve their country. They might vote for a good law, but doing so might lead to steep damages paid to the companies whose behaviour made the new law necessary in the first place. It seriously undermines the country's sovereignty, and that's not something that should be bartered away in secret.


Unfortunately the government gets its money for those damages from its citizens.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: